Recently, several sisters have come forward to me to express how disappointed they are with a couple other sisters with their failed attempt to give advice by being sarcastic. Astaghfirullah. May Allah swt guide them.
Personally, I have been a victim of this myself. With that, I grew to be an exceptionally sensitive person when it comes to accepting criticism because everytime I receive an advice, I can't help but think that the person is out to bring me down but alhamdulillah, now I have understood how to not generalise everyone that way.
See, these sisters or even brothers start out with a good intention mashaAllah; that is to advice the person to be a better muslim but unfortunately, their approach is wrong. What I mean by being sarcastic with attempts to make da'wah is for example, when you see someone that you know has not been a very practising Muslim prays, you make unnecessary comments like "Wow *inserts name here* us praying!!! MashaAllah!". That too, in front of a large crowd. Hence, embarrassing the brother/sister.
My dear advisor, you've just bruised the ego of a person who's attempting to make tawbah & thanks to that, he is never going to pray in front of you or anyone else anymore.
These people do not practise for a reason and it is up to Allah to guide them. I understand how we are to advise these people but there are other ways to make da'wah. For example, should you see this person staying put despite having heard the athaan, encourage him to join you for prayers in a subtle way. If he refuses, leave him alone. Continue doing that for as long as you see him that way while praying to Allah swt to guide him.
Same goes to sisters who observe that Sister *inserts name here* does not wear the hijab. Do not ask questions like "Heyyy sister! When do you plan to wear the Hijab?" Rather, ask questions like "What do you think of the Hijab?"
Also, at the Masjid when you see sisters who are not Hijabees entering the Mosques, DO NOT glare at them with faces that read "Hey sister where's your hijab?" Trust me, they do not appreciate that.
Please, Islam does not teach us to da'wah in such a way & all of us are trying to be good Muslims at the same time. We can only hope that Allah continues to guide us. InshaAllah Ameen.
Take this as a humble advice from your Sister in Islam.
Allah ma'ak,
A'qilah Saiere.